Â鶹ÊÓƵ

Accountability or Responsibility?

Oct 18, 2021

“There's no word for accountability in Finnish. Accountability is something that is left when responsibility has been subtracted.” Finnish Education Minister



“Accountability is done to you. It’s done by those who want to create blame. Responsibility is done by you. It’s voluntary. You can take as much [responsibility] as you want.” (Seth Godin)

In her article ‘5 Simple Ways to Teach your Son about Accountability,’ Cavalot (2020), captures that parenting moment with which we are all familiar:


“I only hit him because he called me an idiot.”


“I only called him an idiot because he broke my toy!”


Cavalot writes, ‘this game is not fun. It can go on forever. And no one ever wins.’ Undeniably, this scenario may render itself differently with daughters or be dependent upon the age of participants, but the essence of the blame game is unaltered: it’s about deflection of personal responsibility. Of course, this is not a skill, or a defect only associated with childhood, this practice re-emerges in adults too. Consequently, that is why the explicit modelling of responsibility needs to start with us as parents and teachers so that our children or students learn to accept not deflect the impact of their behaviour. More easily said than achieved, it would seem.


On topic, I read an online article a few weeks ago, titled ‘Players urged to ditch mates after Cameron Munster, Brandon Smith video emerges.’ What followed was a discussion of a post-end of season party involving Melbourne Storm players which hit social media and included advice of those ‘in the know’ as to how to avoid becoming the subject of public scrutiny.


Allegedly these two players were caught on film taking drugs. Within the article were phrases like, ‘You’ve got to be very careful who you surround yourself with,’ ‘…it’s always the other people around them that are getting them into trouble, not themselves,’ and, ‘Why take that risk? You’ve got a whole life after football to do whatever you like. You can go back into … society and do what you want, but while you’re a professional footballer, understand that there are people out there that are out to get you.’


When I read the article, I was propelled back to the scenario Cavalot (2020) had painted about her sons deflecting responsibility for their actions. This football article was redolent with deflection. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion that the choice to use drugs has consequences, irrespective of social status or employment type. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion that as public figures there is greater responsibility to act lawfully. Nowhere in the article was a suggestion of whether this was the right thing to do or the wrong thing to do. Focus was firmly on blaming the person who filmed and shared the incident – the person who should have said, apparently, ‘hey fellas you are doing the wrong thing.’ There is no doubt that illicit filming and sharing of that which occurs privately bears its own ethical transgressions but that is not the point of this reflection.


The undertone of the article seemed to represent the alleged offenders, those that sign a player code of conduct as part of their contractual obligations, as victims. Not only were they constructed as victims, but the blame was directed everywhere else. I failed to read accountability or responsibility for choice, anywhere. Rather, I read, do what you want but choose who you are with, when you do so. Further, if you get caught, it’s not your fault, it’s the fault of the people who you are with. Whether it takes a code of conduct to impel us in our lawful, moral or ethical choices – such codes exist. They are the written and unwritten laws that bind us to behave in particular ways. When we transgress, who is responsible? Michael Grose (2019) a prolific writer on parenting encapsulates this in such simple terms:


“When you muck up, you make up.” Goal: Responsibility 

“How will you fix this?” Goal: Restoring relationships

“You need to do what’s right, not what’s easy.” Goal: Integrity


Katherine Reynolds Lewis, author of ‘The Good News About Bad Behavior’, spent five years researching how kids mess up, and how [parents] can help them learn to handle those failures, which ultimately will set them up for success. She writes of the long path of parenting and the need to project into adulthood, to 20 years from now. Lewis asks, ‘in 20 years, will it matter more that your child got an A on a test, or learned the value of hard work?’ (cited in Struck, 2019). Cavalot (2020) reminds that facing mistakes or accepting disappointments instead of blaming others is a tough lesson for children and for parents – some never learn it. Sometimes we just learn how to deflect responsibility, how to blame others and how to avoid shame.


To whom and to what are we responsible? How do we learn it? First and foremost, we learn from our parents: the most powerful force on earth. Yet again, it’s starts with our example. Indeed, holding children responsible for their actions is one of the important ways we teach them so that they can become responsible adults. In this sense, it is more important to hold children responsible than adults.



Dr Linda Evans | Principal



References


Cavalot, B. (2021).


Grose, M. (2019). 11 February 2019. Parenting Ideas.


Naghten, T. (2021).  


Struck, J. (2019). March 4, 2019 









More News…

By Graeme Morris 10 Sep, 2024
Storytelling, building connections, and engaging our community is irreplaceable in the marketing strategy of a school. Â鶹ÊÓƵMarketing Manager, Kathryn Doyle, talks about what resonates in modern-day school communication.
By Graeme Morris 10 Sep, 2024
For Year 7 Boarder, Audrey Colville, just getting from her home on Groote Eylandt to Â鶹ÊÓƵis an adventure in itself.
By Graeme Morris 10 Sep, 2024
I enjoy watching Â鶹ÊÓƵsport, debating, dance, choir … (and the list meanders on) – from the sideline. There is joy in watching without responsibility. It does not, as Mr Tregaskis would attest, mean that I do not wince when I see what I believe to be, an incorrect umpire’s decision. You have no idea how much I will miss standing on the sideline observing young people learning to be. After all, these performance arenas are just that – places of becoming. That is, when we, as adults don’t mess with ‘the becoming.’ In anticipation of losing my legitimate reason to watch Â鶹ÊÓƵplay anything, perform anything … I am concentrating on the privilege of the moment. I am soaking in the delights of fiercely contested debating finals, narrow wins and losses on the courts and fields of Toowoomba where the temperature is always colder or hotter than forecast and, the unparalleled joy of Junior School girls dancing on stage without inhibition, some perfectly attuned with the music’s beat and other’s not. I am absorbing the opportunity to witness learning at its essence. Performance in sport or The Arts is a public event. If your artwork is hung in a gallery space it is ‘public’ – open to be appreciated or criticised. If one is singing, dancing, debating or playing an instrument on stage with an audience there is nowhere to hide if an error is made. And, on a court or field – one’s performance is open to scrutiny or praise – or everything in between. Becoming is core business at these times. Anthony Simcoe, perhaps best known for his role as Steve in the epic Australian film, ‘The Castle’ with lines like, “Dale dug a hole, Dad,” or “How much for jousting sticks?” was a gangly fifteen-year-old boy when I first met him at Burnside State High School in Nambour, where he was seeking to master the volleyball dig, serve and set. Who would have imagined his becoming? Even years on, Anthony would say that he learned to become an actor through washing dishes at cafes – earning money between acting jobs – learning to observe the humanness in his customers. He washed a lot of dishes and served a lot of tables in order to become a credible member of ‘The Castle’s’ Kerrigan family. In tedious hours he learned about people and about hard, repetitive work. Repetition is the underpinning pattern of rehearsal and practice. Some of us do it well, others not so. I hear it in action many mornings as I pass the Performing Arts building, I see it on mornings and afternoons in our gym and on our oval. Rehearsal. Practice. Becoming. It is far more palpable; it would seem, than our classroom learning which inhabits a far more private space: often behind a closed door. How special it was, a few weeks ago, to invite the parents of Year 12.1 English to join their daughter, Mrs Anderson and I for a Period Five Friday afternoon lesson of ‘Macbeth.’ Seated in a huge circle in the confines of G24, students directed the lesson: spelling, quotations, thematic discussions and questions, for their parent and the other class members. It was an impressive moment (from a teacher’s perspective anyway) – to see students demonstrate their knowledge in a semi-public forum. It was timely for parents, no doubt, to remember the awkwardness of not knowing an answer, the joy of accuracy as well as the discomfort of feedback about an incorrect assumption – these are aspects of learning with which our students grapple, daily … as they become. There was delight in sharing the messiness of learning, the non-linear path of knowledge and how these segue to ‘becoming.’ Although, that moment of self-actualisation we seek or reaching the mountain top does not come at the same time or in the same way for any of us. And we have to be patient from our sideline position. We have to trust the process. We have to remember also, that losing and missing out are important components of future winning. We have to remember in the words of Saint Ignatius Loyola, Spanish Priest, theologian and thinker, “we learn only when we are ready to learn.” St. Ignatius reminds us that education is not confined to classrooms; it can happen anywhere and at any time: if we allow it. And thus, as adults, as we inhabit more than our fair share of sidelines real and metaphoric, during the rundown to the finish line, let us all be gracious in allowing our young people ‘to become’ … a process that is uneven, at times uncomfortable, messy, deeply disappointing and … often wildly exhilarating. Let us enjoy each and every facet and be gracious in the spaces where alignment with expectation is not met in performance or outcome. It is here, in this place, which can feel unpleasant, unsatisfactory and uninvited that the greatest learning and hence the greatest opportunity to become, can occur. If we, as adults who should know better, don’t mess with ‘the becoming.’ “Another ball game lost! Good grief!” Charlie moans. “I get tired of losing. Everything I do, I lose!” “Look at it this way, Charlie Brown,” Lucy replies. “We learn more from losing than we do from winning.” “That makes me the smartest person in the world!” replies Charlie. Win some. Learn some. Become. Dr Linda Evans │Principal  REFERENCE Maxwell, J. (2013) On Turning a Loss into a Gain | Adapted from Sometimes You Win, Sometimes You Learn (October 2013)
All News
Share by: